All God’s Children

3 out of 5 stars (3 / 5)

In All God’s Children (1996), Thomas Eidson takes readers to a small town in the American west in the late 19th Century where a woman of faith stands alone in her struggle against prejudice and injustice.

Pearl Eddy, the widow of a Kansas farmer of Quaker faith, is the mother of four boys who must find enough work to avoid the forfeiture of her house and farm. Things only get worse for her and her family when she provides shelter to Prophet, a young black man whose circumstances made him a criminal but one who still has some heart left. And if that wasn’t enough, Pearl takes in a family of Japanese migrants who have nowhere to go and are the target of the town’s collective hatred.

All God’s Children is essentially a rather simple story of dramatic conflict between morals and intolerance. Pearl’s character personifies the morals standing on foundations of her faith while her persecutors represent intolerance rooted in racial prejudice. At the same time, the story shines light on the transition of slavery from the older days of holding men and women physically captive to the new age financial slavery of the capitalist system that exploits the misfortune of citizens struggling against circumstances.

Eidson’s pace of storytelling is steady and engaging. The novel’s plot is intimately tied to the characterization and each chapter adds another line and shade to complete the characters’ personalities, much like a figure slowly stepping out of darkness and into the light to be seen in full with clarity. In addition to Pearl and Eddy, Pearl’s oldest son Samuel and the grown-up Asian migrants as well as the special farm rooster Hercules become relatable characters one chapter a time through the course of this story.

Looking critically at Eidson’s All God’s Children, the novel’s lack of proposition and balance in the collective characterization of the story becomes visible. The native white townsfolk are painted with one sweeping stroke of the pen while the migrants and the Eddys are drawn the stark opposite. Readers may be left wondering what happened to the range and diversity of morals in a single community that typically defines all human populations. The ending of the novel is rather anti-climactic. But the message is memorable: we’re all God’s children and deserve to be treated accordingly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.